Canceling an Insurance Claim With Allstate: A Complete Guide

Dealing with car repairs and insurance claims can be a frustrating process. You file a claim expecting your insurer to cover the cost, only to find the payment may not be worth the hassle. So what if you change your mind and want to cancel your claim? Here’s what to know about canceling insurance claims with Allstate.

Can You Cancel a Claim With Allstate?

The short answer is yes – Allstate does allow policyholders to cancel a claim after it’s been filed. Contacting their claims department and speaking with a representative is the best way to cancel a pending claim.

Allstate makes the claims cancellation process simple and straightforward. There are no cancellation fees or penalties. However, canceling a claim does not remove it from your policy records. While minor claims are unlikely to increase your rates, there’s still a chance your premium could go up after a canceled claim.

Below we’ll explore common reasons to cancel an Allstate claim, steps for canceling, effects on your policy, and more.

Why Would You Cancel a Claim?

There are a few smart reasons drivers may want to cancel an insurance claim after filing:

  • Avoid rate increases – Even minor claims can sometimes cause premium hikes. If repairs will cost less than expected rate increases, paying out of pocket makes sense.

  • Change repair plans – You filed a claim planning to repair damage, but have since decided not to fix the vehicle.

  • Settling outside insurance – For minor fender benders with agreeable drivers, resolving damages between yourselves without a claim is easier.

  • Dissatisfaction with insurer – Unhappy with Allstate’s service? Canceling gives you a chance to find a new provider.

  • Met deductible limit – If your deductible exceeds the claim value, you’ll have to pay that amount anyway.

Essentially, if the claim payment from Allstate isn’t worth the hassle or financial impact, canceling the claim avoids unnecessary costs.

How to Cancel an Allstate Insurance Claim

Allstate wants to make canceling a claim simple for customers. Here are the steps to withdraw a claim:

  • Call claims department – Contact Allstate’s claims customer service line at 1-800-547-8676. This is the quickest and most direct method.

  • Contact your adjuster – Locate the direct number for the claims adjuster handling your case and call them.

  • Visit a local office – Head to your nearest Allstate agency and speak with an agent face-to-face.

  • Send secure message – Log into your Allstate account and send a message through your claims dashboard.

Provide your full name, claim number, and policy number when canceling. Allstate requires verbal or written confirmation from the policyholder to cancel.

How Canceling a Claim Affects Your Policy

Canceling your claim with Allstate seems easy enough. But how does withdrawing a claim impact your insurance policy and rates going forward? Here’s what to expect:

  • Claim stays on record – The canceled claim itself will remain in Allstate’s records tied to your policy. This protects against fraud.

  • No reimbursement – You won’t receive any payment or reimbursement for damages once the claim is canceled.

  • Possible premium increase – Even canceled claims may cause rates to rise at renewal time. Typically only major claims significantly impact premiums.

  • Ineligibility for discounts – After a claim, you may lose certain discounts like a claims-free policy bonus.

  • Renewal availability – Too many claims within a policy term could make it difficult to renew coverage.

While Allstate won’t directly punish drivers for canceling a claim, you give up your reimbursement dollars and run the risk of increased premiums down the road. Weigh that risk before filing a claim or calling to cancel.

When Can You Not Cancel a Claim?

Most claims can be canceled upon request, but some situations won’t allow a withdrawal:

  • Third-party injury claims – If someone else was injured in an accident caused by you, these liability claims cannot be canceled.

  • Totaled vehicles – Once Allstate deems your car a total loss, the process cannot be reversed.

  • Claims referred for investigation – Suspicious or fraudulent claims will be investigated regardless and can’t be canceled.

  • Claims involving lawsuits – Legal claims tied up in court proceedings cannot be canceled by the policyholder alone.

  • Closed claims – Once Allstate closes a claim and issues payment, it’s too late to cancel and withdraw.

Bottom line – liability claims covering other drivers and closed claims with paid settlements cannot be canceled.

Steps to Take Before Canceling an Allstate Claim

Canceling an insurance claim is a big decision. Before calling Allstate to withdraw your claim, consider taking these steps:

  • Review your policy – Understand how claims impact your rates, discounts, and renewal eligibility. Know the potential consequences.

  • Calculate damages – Estimate your out-of-pocket costs if you pay for repairs yourself after withdrawing the claim.

  • Get repair quotes – Ask auto shops for repair estimates so you can compare to your claim settlement offer.

  • Read claim documents – Review letters, estimates, and details from Allstate to ensure canceling is your best option.

  • Check state laws – Some states restrict claim cancellations. Verify it’s allowed in your region.

  • Discuss with agent – Your Allstate agent can explain how canceling may affect your particular policy. Their insight is invaluable.

Doing your due diligence will ensure canceling your claim is the optimal choice financially and logistically. Never cancel a claim on impulse – make an informed decision.

Alternatives to Canceling an Allstate Claim

Canceling your claim isn’t the only option if you’re unsatisfied with Allstate’s customer service or claims response. Here are a few other paths to consider first:

  • Discuss concerns with agent – Your agent may be able to resolve problems with adjusters or get answers about your claim.

  • Request a review – Ask to have a claim manager or supervisor re-examine the claim and settlement.

  • Provide additional information – Supplying photos, estimates, or documentation may lead to a better settlement.

  • File complaint with department of insurance – You can report poor service or claim denial issues to your state’s insurance regulators.

  • Consult an attorney – For very complex claims involving injuries, legal help may be advisable before withdrawing your claim.

  • Switch providers – If you’re generally unhappy with Allstate, canceling your policy to find a new insurer may be wiser than canceling just one claim.

Don’t rush to cancel your claim if other options may improve your settlement and experience. Consider all avenues for resolving your issues with Allstate’s claims process before withdrawal.

What Happens If You’ve Already Received Payment?

What if you want to cancel your Allstate claim but have already deposited the claim payment check or received repair reimbursement? Is it too late?

You may still be able to cancel your Allstate claim in this scenario if you:

  • Return the full claim payment – Send Allstate’s money back to withdraw the claim.

  • Pay repair shop directly – The shop refunds Allstate’s payment and bills you instead.

  • Demonstrate inability to pay – Show financial hardship makes returning the funds impossible.

Any other arrangements would require Allstate’s approval. Otherwise they will be unable to void a claim after issuing payment. Don’t spend claim settlements until certain you won’t need to cancel.

Our Final Take: Is Canceling Claims With Allstate Worth It?

Canceling an insurance claim is sometimes necessary if settling out of pocket makes more financial sense or Allstate’s service is unsatisfactory. But will canceling actually benefit you in the long run? Here are our final recommendations:

  • For major claims, file the claim – The risk of increased premiums is worth comprehensive repairs.

  • For minor claims below your deductible, cancel – Paying your deductible makes more sense.

  • If claim disputes arise, escalate within Allstate first – Immediately canceling should be a last resort.

  • To prevent premium hikes, avoid frequent claims – Drivers who never file claims get the lowest rates.

  • If you want to switch insurers, cancel at renewal time – Don’t cancel mid-policy since claims will still impact your record.

  • Consult your Allstate agent to understand policy impacts – Their guidance will help you make the optimal choice.

With Allstate’s helpful claims representatives and easy cancellation process, you can easily withdraw a pending claim. But exercise caution and only cancel if absolutely necessary – it won’t erase the claim from your history entirely. By making prudent choices, you can protect your Allstate policy and premium.

Can you cancel your insurance after you file a claim


Can you file a claim and then cancel it?

Key Takeaways. You can cancel an insurance claim after filing it. You can even do this after your insurer has issued you a check, as long as you haven’t cashed it. If you’re at fault, you can cancel the claim for the damages your vehicle sustained, but not the one the other driver filed.

How do I withdraw my insurance claim?

Give them a call, get a representative on the phone, and tell them you want to withdraw (appropriate language is also “cancel”) your claim. So long as it’s allowable, they should take care of it right away.

Does Allstate charge a cancellation fee?

Allstate does not impose a cancellation fee or penalty for early termination.

Can I cancel my car insurance with an open claim?

Even if you just started your coverage or have a pending claim, you should be able to cancel your current policy with no penalties. Once you’ve secured coverage with a new insurance company, be sure to contact your agent or current insurer and let them know the effective date of your cancellation.

Leave a Comment