Why Do Many Dentists Not Accept HMO Insurance?

When searching for a new dentist, you may find that many don’t accept HMO dental insurance plans. There are several key reasons dentists tend to avoid participating in HMO networks. Understanding these factors can help you make an informed insurance decision.

What is HMO Dental Insurance?

First, a quick overview of how HMO dental coverage works:

  • HMO stands for “Health Maintenance Organization”. It is a type of managed care plan.

  • With HMO dental insurance, you must choose from a limited network of dentists. Treatment by out-of-network dentists is typically not covered except for emergencies.

  • You pay lower premiums for HMO dental plans compared to PPO insurance.

  • There are no claims to file as your dentist handles all paperwork and billing directly with the HMO.

  • No deductible is required, and copays for services are preset rather than variable percentage coinsurance.

  • You need a referral from your primary dentist to see specialists.

  • Pre-authorization from the HMO is required for major treatments like crowns or braces.

This managed approach to dental care keeps costs lower for the insurance company and subscribers. But it also imposes many restrictions on participating dentists.

Why Do Dentists Avoid HMO Insurance Plans?

There are several key reasons many dentists choose not to accept HMO insurance:

Lower Reimbursement Rates

HMOs negotiate set reimbursement rates for dental procedures with in-network dentists. These agreed rates are often significantly lower than what dentists normally charge patients.

One survey found HMO reimbursement averages 20-50% less than typical fees in a dentist’s region. These lower rates equate to reduced revenue for the dental practice.

Delayed Claim Payments

In addition to lower payment amounts, HMOs are notorious for slow reimbursement to dentists.

While PPO dental plans usually pay claims within 30-60 days, HMOs often take 90-120 days to reimburse dentists. This strains cash flow for the practice.

Pre-Authorization Requirements

HMOs require dentists to submit treatment plans and get pre-approval before performing complex, expensive procedures. This administrative step takes time and the HMO may deny or alter the treatment recommendation.

Appointment Scheduling Limits

HMOs limit the number of plan participants each dentist can see. This avoids oversaturation but restricts appointment availability. Dentists may decline HMO participation to maintain more flexible scheduling.

Less Autonomy

Under HMO contracts, the insurance company makes coverage rules. Dentists sacrifice clinical autonomy for the financial trade-offs and administrative burdens of managed care plans.

Assigned Dentists

Unlike PPO networks which allow participant choice, HMO members are assigned a specific primary dentist. This restricts patient selection for dentists.

Office Location

HMOs may limit provider networks to specific zip codes and regions. So a dentist’s office location determines eligibility to join an HMO network.

Do Any Dentists Accept HMO Insurance?

While many dentists avoid HMOs, some do participate in networks. Newly established practices often join HMOs to quickly build a patient base.

Also, certain dentists devote their practice to low-cost care and don’t mind the HMO trade-offs. Corporately owned dental chains and clinics are more likely to accept HMOs than small private practices.

However, dentists on HMO panels tend to churn quickly due to frustrations over low pay, delays, and administration burdens. As a result, HMO networks suffer from instability and access limitations compared to PPO plans.

Alternatives to HMO Dental Insurance

If your dentist does not participate in HMOs, you have alternatives for lowering dental costs:

  • PPO Insurance – While premiums are higher, PPO plans offer broader choice of dentists and fewer usage restrictions. Many dentists accept PPO coverage.

  • Dental Discount Plans – These are lower cost than insurance and provide access to discounted rates from a network of dentists. No claims paperwork is required.

  • Pay Cash – Without the overhead of billing insurance, some dentists offer cash discounts of 5-15% for patients who pay out-of-pocket.

  • Dental Schools – Students and faculty at dental schools provide low-cost care under supervision from experienced dentists.

  • Dental Tourism – For extensive treatment, traveling internationally can mean savings of up to 50-75% on care.

  • Care Credit – This medical credit card offers interest-free financing for 6-12 months to pay for treatment.

Using one of these alternatives may allow you to continue seeing your preferred dentist while minimizing costs.

Tips for Finding HMO Dentists

If you want to enroll in an HMO dental plan, here are some tips for finding a qualified dentist:

  • Check the HMO provider directory to see dentists accepting new patients in your area.

  • Look for dentists who have participated in the HMO network for several years. This may indicate greater stability.

  • Search online reviews for feedback on dentists’ chairside manner, explanation of treatments, and communication style.

  • Schedule a consultation to meet HMO dentists before your next cleaning or checkup.

  • Ask how long appointments are scheduled for – HMOs pressure dentists to minimize visit times.

  • Inquire about assistance getting specialist referrals or pre-authorizations if needed down the road.

  • Consider location, availability of evening and weekend hours, wait times for appointments, and accessibility.

Key Takeaways

  • Many dentists do not accept HMO insurance due to lower payment rates, claim delays, administrative burdens, and lack of autonomy.

  • However, some newer, corporate, and low-cost focused dental practices do participate in HMO networks.

  • If your dentist does not take HMO coverage, PPO plans, discount dental plans, cash discounts, dental schools, and medical credit cards can help reduce costs.

  • When evaluating HMO dentists, look at experience, reviews, appointment availability, and responsiveness.

  • Ask questions to get a sense of the dentist’s communication style and how well they educate patients.

While finding a quality dentist on an HMO plan may take effort and research, the cost savings of this type of dental insurance can be significant. Weigh affordability against dentist choice and practice limitations when selecting the right coverage option.

Why do dentists not accept HMO?


Is PPO better than HMO dental?

Generally speaking, DHMO plans are more cost effective, while PPO dental plans offer greater flexibility. There’s no way of saying that one plan is better than the other – it just comes down to which will meet your unique needs.

Why do dentists choose not to network?

Dentists may leave provider networks due to disagreement over treatment options. Some networks may have restrictions on the types of procedures or materials that dentists are allowed to use, which can be frustrating for dentists who want to provide the best possible care for their patients.

Why would a person choose a PPO over an HMO?

HMOs don’t offer coverage for care from out-of-network healthcare providers. The only exception is for true medical emergencies. With a PPO, you have the flexibility to visit providers outside of your network. However, visiting an out-of-network provider will include a higher fee and a separate deductible.

Leave a Comment